What other data should I be pulling if I wanted to mathematically with some randomness have two guild members fight? Here is a sample of what I can pull:

Droogan
70
Priest
Troll
23 : 38 : 0
HP: 5811
Mana/Second Bar: 8490
Strength: 40
Agility: 47
Stamina: 260
Intellect: 410
Spirit: 443
Armor: 2557
Main Hand Damage: 63.6
Off Hand Damage: 1.3
Melee Crit: 3.70
Ranged Damage: 102.1
Ranged Crit: 5.06
Bonus Healing: 982
Mana Regen: 377.00
Arcane Spell Damage: 438
Arcane Spell Crit: 6.36
Fire Spell Damage: 438
Fire Spell Crit: 6.36
Frost Spell Damage: 438
Frost Spell Crit: 6.36
Holy Spell Damage: 438
Holy Spell Crit: 11.36
Nature Spell Damage: 438
Nature Spell Crit: 6.36
Shadow Spell Damage: 438
Shadow Spell Crit: 6.36
Alchemy: 346
Enchanting: 276

Jerryatric
70
Hunter
Troll
41 : 20 : 0
HP: 8341
Mana/Second Bar: 6868
Strength: 89
Agility: 541
Stamina: 471
Intellect: 251
Spirit: 158
Armor: 5748
Main Hand Damage: 220.1
Off Hand Damage: 63.7
Melee Crit: 17.02
Ranged Damage: 348.4
Ranged Crit: 24.29
Bonus Healing: 15
Mana Regen: 123.00
Arcane Spell Damage: 15
Arcane Spell Crit: 6.74
Fire Spell Damage: 15
Fire Spell Crit: 6.74
Frost Spell Damage: 15
Frost Spell Crit: 6.74
Holy Spell Damage: 15
Holy Spell Crit: 6.74
Nature Spell Damage: 15
Nature Spell Crit: 6.74
Shadow Spell Damage: 15
Shadow Spell Crit: 6.74
Leatherworking: 375
Skinning: 375

Bhain
70
Paladin
Blood Elf
0 : 49 : 12
HP: 18517
Mana/Second Bar: 5763
Strength: 135
Agility: 100
Stamina: 1517
Intellect: 206
Spirit: 173
Armor: 15747
Main Hand Damage: 76.3
Off Hand Damage: 0.0
Melee Crit: 4.65
Ranged Damage: 0.0
Ranged Crit: 4.25
Bonus Healing: 420
Mana Regen: 124.00
Arcane Spell Damage: 420
Arcane Spell Crit: 5.91
Fire Spell Damage: 420
Fire Spell Crit: 5.91
Frost Spell Damage: 420
Frost Spell Crit: 5.91
Holy Spell Damage: 420
Holy Spell Crit: 5.91
Nature Spell Damage: 420
Nature Spell Crit: 5.91
Shadow Spell Damage: 420
Shadow Spell Crit: 5.91
Blacksmithing: 375
Jewelcrafting: 375

Maniafolder
70
Rogue
Undead
19 : 42 : 0
HP: 8894
Mana/Second Bar: 100
Strength: 100
Agility: 505
Stamina: 537
Intellect: 43
Spirit: 69
Armor: 3297
Main Hand Damage: 221.6
Off Hand Damage: 169.6
Melee Crit: 23.58
Ranged Damage: 239.5
Ranged Crit: 21.38
Bonus Healing: 0
Mana Regen: 0.00
Arcane Spell Damage: 0
Arcane Spell Crit: 0.00
Fire Spell Damage: 0
Fire Spell Crit: 0.00
Frost Spell Damage: 0
Frost Spell Crit: 0.00
Holy Spell Damage: 0
Holy Spell Crit: 0.00
Nature Spell Damage: 0
Nature Spell Crit: 0.00
Shadow Spell Damage: 0
Shadow Spell Crit: 0.00
Leatherworking: 375
Mining: 375

---

Lighten up while you still can
don't even try to understand
Just find a place to make your stand
and take it easy

resillience probably. thats an important pvp one.

[[Coward:Jerryatric:Peteyatric]]Coward - 83 Prot Warrior
Jerryatric - 72 Marks Hunter
Peteyatric - 70 Holy Priest

For Resilience I can pull:

[DAMAGEPERCENT] => 6.65
[HITPERCENT] => 3.32
[VALUE] => 131.00

Not sure which is which, but I do know I have none on Droogan. The above stats are from Dhain.

---

Lighten up while you still can
don't even try to understand
Just find a place to make your stand
and take it easy

I guess I should pull out defense, dodge, parry, block as well.

---

Lighten up while you still can
don't even try to understand
Just find a place to make your stand
and take it easy

What does having tailoring or blacksmithing have to do with who would win a fight?

There should also be an intangible factor. Sometimes one just wins duels based on pure leetness, adn you can't measure that.

Achievement Earned! Attend a guild party in real life.